The atmospheric properties of distant worlds are becoming increasingly clear.
The latest observations reveal fluorescent emission from methane in the upper
atmosphere of a Jupiter-like extrasolar planet.
The first extrasolar planet found to be orbiting a Sun-like star was detected
less than 15 years ago. As astronomers detect more and more planets orbiting
stars other than the Sun in our Galactic neighbourhood, increasing attention is
being paid to probing their atmospheres, and for good reason. Planetary
atmospheres can be easily altered by geophysical1, photochemical2 and
biological3 processes. Owing to the relatively small amount of mass in an
atmosphere, its properties can bear the signatures of processes driven from the
planetary interior or surface that would not otherwise be observable. A notable
example is the presence of the powerful greenhouse gas methane (CH4) in
planetary atmospheres.
In Earth's atmosphere, the dominant sources of non-anthropogenic methane are
anaerobic bacteria and methanogens, which inhabit wetland and oceanic sediments,
and the digestive tracts of some organisms (for example, ruminants and
termites). Methanogens, like most archaeal microorganisms, can thrive in a wide
range of conditions, including many that would be harmful to the bulk of complex
life forms on Earth. Jupiter's methane, meanwhile, is photochemical in origin,
and so is dependent on the radiation field incident on the atmosphere and the
specific abundances of carbon, oxygen and hydrogen4.
To disentangle the various processes that affect an atmosphere, it is crucial to
obtain as much information as possible on a diverse sample of planetary
atmospheres. On page 637 of this issue, Swain et al.5 report the discovery of
fluorescent emission from methane in the upper atmosphere of a nearby,
Jupiter-mass extrasolar planet6, HD 189733b
Fluorescence occurs when an atom or molecule absorbs a photon, is excited
into a higher energy state and subsequently de-excites, emitting light at lower
energies. It requires the relatively low particle densities that occur high in
planetary atmospheres, where the time between collisions is longer than the time
required for radiative relaxation. Methane, like all molecules, can only make
such transitions among specific permitted electronic, rotational and vibrational
energy pathways that are unique to its molecular structure. The result is a
characteristic spectrum of emission lines, and it is one of these emission
lines, distinctive to methane, that has been detected by Swain and colleagues5.
Fluorescent emission is relatively common in astrophysical environments. It has
been detected, for example, in the accretion disks surrounding supermassive
black holes7, in the interstellar medium8 and in comets9. Specifically, the
fluorescent methane emission detected by Swain et al.5 on HD 189733b has also
been observed in the atmospheres of Jupiter, Saturn and Titan10. Fluorescence of
other organic compounds has been detected on Venus and Mars11. These detections
provide a probe of the physical structure of the upper atmosphere of these
planets from the perspective of a minor atmospheric constituent. Methane is
particularly important because it may help us to find and evaluate possible
biological influences on extrasolar planetary atmospheres.
The upper atmosphere is a fascinating and important region where minor molecular
constituents, such as methane, can play an indispensable part in establishing
the overall heat budget of a planet, thereby altering the thermal profile of a
considerable portion of the atmosphere. Powerful winds and vertical mixing of
high-altitude atmospheric layers present the possibility for temporal and
spatial variability of the fluorescent emission from such molecules. In
addition, ionized particles in the upper atmosphere are affected by any global
magnetic field — as is dramatically exemplified on Earth by another form of
emission-line radiation, the aurorae. Because HD 189733b is extremely close to
its host star (less than one-tenth the distance between Mercury and the Sun),
energetic particles from its star will interact with any magnetic field the
planet may have, possibly resulting in stronger emission-line displays than we
see on Earth or Jupiter. Many other observed extrasolar planets are similarly
close to their host stars, so variability in emission components because of
magnetic effects may be common in these systems.
Swain and colleagues' detection5 of a fluorescent emission line of methane on HD
189733b paves the way for future observations of alternative fluorescent
emission lines of methane and other molecules in extrasolar planetary
atmospheres. These observations will require sensitive, high-spectral-resolution
instruments that can resolve the emission-line profile of fluorescent signals.
In addition, this discovery highlights a crucial theme in modern astronomy: the
necessity of making complementary observations from the ground and from space.
Depending on the wavelengths of the relevant spectral features, Earth's own
atmosphere may or may not interfere with detection. The authors' observations5
were made with the 3.0-metre NASA Infrared Telescope Facility located at the
summit of Mauna Kea in Hawaii. Our increasing understanding of this one
extrasolar planet — from its discovery6 to the growing list of known
constituents of its atmosphere, which includes sodium12, carbon monoxide13,
carbon dioxide13, water vapour13 and methane14 — has been possible only with
observations from both the ground and space.
During the past few years, we have made a transition that deserves some
rumination. Rather than speculating about the possibility of other worlds in the
cosmos, we can now identify them specifically and enumerate their various
characteristics. Many stars that are readily visible to the naked eye, at least
from relatively dark sites that are not heavily polluted by artificial light,
have planets orbiting them, the masses and orbital characteristics of which we
know. A number of other worlds, soon to be discovered, will be small and rocky
like Earth, and will have atmospheres that we can detect, inventory and monitor.
It is quite possible that, within our lifetimes, atmospheric studies of these
extrasolar planets will provide the first evidence of biological life beyond
Earth. Swain and colleagues' detection of the fluorescence of a hydrocarbon in
the upper atmosphere of an extrasolar planet not only provides insight into the
structure of the atmospheres of other worlds, but is also an important step in
the far-reaching journey to uncover what may be below them
|